Pastor Name |
From |
To |
| James E. Hughes | April 1855 | September 1855 |
| James Francis Smith | September 1855 | October 1857 |
| Jesse A. Hollis | December 1857 | July 1859 |
| James Green Smith | July 1859 | May 1863 |
| Noah Cate | May 1863 | January 1864 |
| William Henry Burnham | January 1864 | January 1868 |
| Sylvester A. Beauchamp | February 1868 | January 1870 |
| Wiley Jones Patrick | April 1870 | April 1871 |
| Henry McQueen Richardson | July 1871 | February 1873 |
| William Ferguson | July 1873 | August 1874 |
| William F. Kone | March 1875 | December 1875 |
| Brooking T. Taylor | March 1876 | March 1877 |
| William M. Tipton | April 1877 | April 1878 |
| James Francis Smith | February 1880 | April 1883 |
| John M. P. Martin | November 1883 | May 1886 |
| Alfred E. Rogers | October 1886 | June 1890 |
| Charles William Dicken | July 1890 | September 1891 |
| W. G. Thomas | January 1892 | April 1894 |
| William H. Shelton Jr. | April 1894 | March 1897 |
| Howard Weeks | June 1897 | September 1897 |
| Benjamin George Tutt | September 1897 | October 1900 |
| James Percy Stuart | March 1901 | September 1902 |
| George H. Swift | November 1902 | September 1907 |
| Hiter Nelson Quisenberry | March 1908 | March 1910 |
| James Arthur Taylor | August 1910 | January 1918 |
| Everett Gill | February 1918 | June 1918 |
| Ernest Malone Harris | June 1918 | November 1920 |
| Asa Q. Burns | November 1920 | July 1921 |
| Dr. Jesse Coleman Owen | July 1921 | May 1924 |
| Dr. A. Welby Tandy | February 1925 | November 1933 |
| Cleates E. Hanan | July 1934 | December 1939 |
| John Robert Steers | June 1940 | February 1943 |
| Cleates E. Hanan | July 1943 | December 1957 |
| Lewis M. Krause | April 1958 | July 1962 |
| Harold D. Garrett | April 1963 | July 1966 |
| J. Frank Kirkland | November 1966 | July 1973 |
| Dr. James L. Goodson | November 1973 | March 1977 |
| Allen Bartlett | August 1977 | October 1990 |
| Stephen Sowder | September 1991 | October 2007 |